The Mazda MX-5 Miata stands as the benchmark for accessible sports cars. Its lightweight design, rear-wheel drive, and available manual transmission deliver a pure driving experience unmatched in its price bracket. Starting at just $29,830, the Miata’s appeal lies in its simplicity and balance. However, for those seeking alternatives, several options exist, each offering a different blend of performance, comfort, and style. This guide explores ten alternatives, ranging from direct competitors to more luxurious drop-tops.
Toyota GR86 (MSRP: $30,800)
The Toyota GR86 is the Miata’s closest rival. Like the Miata, it prioritizes handling over raw power, delivering a well-balanced driving experience. Its 228-horsepower naturally aspirated engine offers more grunt than the Miata’s 181 hp, and the GR86 adds two extra rear seats for practicality.
Subaru BRZ (MSRP: $33,210)
Essentially the GR86’s twin, the Subaru BRZ shares the same rear-wheel drive setup, available manual transmission, and charismatic flat-four engine. The BRZ’s “tS” trim adds track-focused dampers, upgraded Brembo brakes, and blue interior stitching, though at a higher price point.
Mini Cooper S Convertible (Average Value: $19,914)
For a quirky and stylish alternative, the Mini Cooper S Convertible offers peppy handling and a distinctive British flair. While front-wheel drive, it delivers a fun driving experience, though the ride can be rough at times. Its 189 horsepower matches the Miata’s performance.
Audi A3 Convertible (Average Value: $22,010)
The Audi A3 Convertible offered a premium drop-top experience with either 184 or 228 horsepower. While lacking a manual transmission and prioritizing comfort over track handling, it provided usable rear seats and a refined interior. This model was discontinued after 2019.
BMW 230i xDrive Convertible (Average Value: $27,764)
The BMW 2 Series convertible blends luxury and performance. With 248 horsepower and an optional all-wheel drive system, it offers a more upscale experience than the Miata, though the standard eight-speed automatic transmission diminishes its raw sports car appeal.
Mercedes-Benz SLC (Average Value: $29,097)
The SLC-Class, a rebadged SLK, emphasizes luxury and style. Its 241-horsepower engine provides ample power, but sacrifices the Miata’s lightweight balance and pure handling dynamics. For those prioritizing refinement over raw engagement, the SLC is a compelling option.
Audi TT Roadster (Average Value: $30,819)
The Audi TT Roadster stands out with its sharp styling and turbocharged engine options: 228 horsepower on standard models and 288 on the TTS. All-wheel drive and a seven-speed automatic transmission are standard, making it a more premium choice than the Miata.
BMW Z4 sDrive30i (Average Value: $32,867)
The BMW Z4 offers a blend of luxury and performance. With 255 horsepower, it delivers satisfying handling, though it lacks the Miata’s meticulous balance. The Z4 prioritizes upscale interiors and head-turning aesthetics over raw driving engagement.
Nissan Z (Average Value: $32,991)
The modern Nissan Z delivers a significant performance jump over the Miata. With 400 horsepower and a twin-turbocharged V6, it accelerates under five seconds to 60 mph. While more expensive, the Z offers exotic looks and substantial power.
Porsche 718 Boxster (Average Value: $38,641)
The Porsche 718 Boxster represents the ultimate alternative to the Miata. With comparable handling and performance, it offers a more luxurious experience, though maintenance costs are significantly higher. Its turbocharged flat-four engines and expertly tuned chassis make it a true sports car.
Ultimately, the Miata remains the benchmark for affordable thrills. However, these alternatives provide a range of options for those seeking a different blend of performance, luxury, and style
